Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Colonel Digger Rotelli.'s avatar

Let me be clear. Berger lied. Smith is lying. Nothing to close ranks on. Bergers retired, and Smith needs to be fired.

Expand full comment
Douglas C Rapé's avatar

DEI and other efforts of similar impact with different names and titles was alive and well through my entire career from 1974-2000. What was limited grew in size and intensity and exploded after I retired.

I first became aware of a dilution of merit while at my University 1970-74. I embraced the Marine Corps as a pure meritocracy at PLC Juniors in 1971. Once on active duty in 1974 I saw little of it but the beginnings were starting to show. By 1990 I became more aware of it but noted that resistance to “other than merit” decisions started to falter. By the time of my retirement in 2000 the seeds had been strewn far and wide and like weeds it was spreading. Pointing it out became increasingly divisive and unwelcome.

Sadly, some saw it in everything when it was not. Others saw none of it when it was obvious. The fact the merit was questioned at every turn, often justly, often as a figment of imagination and often just ignored

, caused a deeper problem. It undermined trust which is the critical element in leadership in war fighting institutions. That erosion of trust was the cancer in the institution. In the 25 years since my retirement the impact has been considerable. To pretend it never happened only makes it worse. Admit it, fix it and move forward. Anything else is either ignorance or a lie.

Expand full comment
6 more comments...

No posts