Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Polarbear's avatar

Madness

And here it is: In China’s backyard: The New Marine Regiments Changing the Fight

https://www.marinecorpstimes.com/news/your-marine-corps/2024/05/13/in-chinas-backyard-the-new-marine-regiments-changing-the-fight/

The MLR “It’s just sized and purpose-built for its task, which is to be light, lethal and austere and to be able to stand in the weapons engagement zone when others are going to have to leave because of the threat,” he told War on the Rocks in 2023.

“They are exactly what we need in the Pacific,” Smith said. “It is the best solution to the task we’ve been given.”

And that task is to enable the Navy to fight the naval fight.”

The purpose of the MLR …”is to stand in the engagement zone when others are going to leave because of the threat”.

This is madness. A war in the Pacific will not be about control of engagement zones, it will be about control of SLOCs. The MLR is not going to control its own SLOCs with 100 mile area denial missiles. They are going to be easily isolated and neutralize. Wake Island surrendered; Corregidor surrendered; Rabual, (the largest Japanese base in the South Pacific) was neutralized and surrendered after the war.

This “purpose” represents a fundamental flaw in the strategic thinking of General Berger, (and now) General Smith, and the SECNAV. What will control SLOCs is the ability to seize advanced bases and airfields. A2/AD missiles (and drones) have a role but they will not be decisive. What will be decisive will be aircraft. The WW2 Pacific War was not about engagement zones. It was about air superiority. We seized islands for their airfields in order to capture, isolate and neutralize the enemy’s controlled SLOCs

Why do I feel like General Smith is fighting wind mills riding a General Berger horse named Rocinante. The United States Marine Corps purpose is simple and clear; it is amphibious assault.

Expand full comment
Ray “Skip” Polak's avatar

Dog! OK recall Reckless the horse in Korea who saved a more than a few Marines. Program a dog to help there, too.

Next: my take away—-Ukrainians are out gunned. Are we now out gunned? We divested our tube artillery for rockets, which may not be as useful in for door to door, danger close situations. Just a musing from an old gunner-proudly so, old and gunner!

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts