Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Douglas C Rapé's avatar

1. Just the Iranian ramp up in Missiles is a threat. For 47 years Iran has threatened to destroy us and we have tried everything to appease them to no avail. We should believe them. There is not much chance of an amphibious assault. The Marine Corps gave away that capability so time ago.

2. Any proof the three F-15’s ran out of fuel on their way home? That would take the investigation into a simpler direction….

2. The State Department has encouraged US citizens to leave 14 countries across the Muslim world in a band stretching 6000 miles. They are largely on their own. Not so long ago multiple MEUs would have been ready to conduct Non Combatant Evacuations. Right now we could use one in the Mediterranean, the Indian Ocean and the South Pacific for that very reason. There are none available. Some departures may be permissive and some may come to resemble the fiasco in Kabul. Some could look like Cambodia or S Vietnam. Some like Beirut. That is immaterial. The fact remains that our MEUs are not able to do it and can’t get there anyway.

A mob with firearms just tried to storm the Consulate in Karachi. The Marine Embassy Guards repelled them with small arms. Are they being reinforced? No MEU available. Maybe MCSF are on their way. Lift via the USAF. Maybe not.

The fact remains the current MAGTF’s are a mere shadow of what they once were and we lack the Amphib shipping to keep them patrolling the seas. The USMC EABO efforts have zero applicability in the above circumstances. Zero.

Ultimately Congress is going to ask why we even have a Marine Corps or at least one as large as it is. Once you are irrelevant you lose funding and manpower. You then become even less relevant, end up obsolete and are eventually reduced to a small ceremonial outfit before finally and without fanfare disbanded. If you are an optimist you become an Amphibious Division of the US Army before you go the way of the horse cavalry.

Six years ago the Corps knew it needed some modernization of our MAGTFs and we needed more Amphibs. The solution was EABO which solved nothing and everyone who saw through the gross stupidity of it was tarred as “resistant to change”. These are the magic words to kill any opponent resistant to ill advised and flawed change. When you have a problem you must embrace a change provided it is the right change. The last two Commandants embraced the wrong change and the Corps is now irrelevant in the conflicts of our times.

Jim McDonnell's avatar

The United States Marines do have a score to settle with Hezbollah for what they did to our brothers in Beirut in October 1983. Nobody ever did anything about that.

6 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?