Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Bud Meador's avatar

In referencing the ROK dilemma of living next door to China, and our need to be able to quickly move to their defense, I recall Gen. Barrow’s reference to Nathan Bedford Forrest’s dictum: “Git there firstest with the mostest”, put the skir on ‘em & keep it there”. We might want to reflect on that. Once again, let History temper our judgment. Semper Fi!

Expand full comment
Polarbear's avatar

Island Chain Strategy

https://intpolicydigest.org/china-has-almost-breached-the-first-island-containment-chain/

You do not develop national strategy with a crayon mark drawn across a map of the Pacific. Especially when the crayon mark is on the wrong side of the South China Sea. Nor do you form a strategy by mimicking the CCP’s “island chain” strategy. It plays the strategic advantage card into their hands. The first island chain has already been penetrated and it basically sends a signal you are prepared to surrender a hand full of your allies and friends (Taiwan, Korea, Viet Nam) on the wrong side of the line.

The US Marine Corps Amphibious MAGTFs have a role to play in the “great power completion” and a peer-to-peer conflict with the CCP. The Navy and Marine Corps currently have one MEU tied up in the Red Sea Area (CENTCOM). The US should have at least another MEU cutting circles around those man made islands in the South China Seas. It would also be strategically advantageous if INDOPACOM had second MEU in the Indian Ocean and the Straits of Malacca. Remember the South China Sea extends all the way to the Straits of Singapore. Let’s not forget that the WW2 Japanese invaded Malaysia with a series of amphibious assaults on the eastern coast and a few thousand bicycles to capture Singapore in 70 days.

https://www.welovecycling.com/wide/2019/06/28/japanese-style-bicycle-blitzkrieg/

My concern is that at least Marine CP has pointed out all the related issues with the 2030 Design spawned by a bad strategy. Congress seems to have noticed by tasking the US Marine Corps to provide answers. Why are they waiting for the answers when they are obvious? Is the Marine Corps and Navy leadership delaying for a new administration?

"And a resolution adopted by the CCP Central Committee in November 2021 stated, "Resolving the Taiwan question and realizing China’s complete reunification is a historic mission and an unshakable commitment of the Party."

Expand full comment
6 more comments...

No posts