Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Cpl Dan USMC (Ret)'s avatar

FD2030’s Blind Spot

Compass Points’ March 19 “Ubiquitous China” lays it bare—China’s everywhere—Pacific, Africa, Arctic—FD2030’s MLR locks on one spot—five years, 3,700 tank billets cut—25,000 MAGTF slashed—Smith’s narrow aim—General Gray’s MAGTF didn't blink, the Marine Corps was ready to take on anything.

Facts Over Focus Testing: FD2030—MCWL sims, 2019-2021—no Title 10 standalone—3rd MLR—HIMARS, 600 km—China’s 4,000 km—“narrow tests flop!” Scope: China-only—Indo-Pacific zero MAGTFs—USNI Tracker, March 10—Africa, Arctic exposed—“narrow leaves gaps!" Proof: Ukraine—2,700 tanks, decisive—IDF doubles tanks—FD2030’s MLR—outgunned“narrow focus means big loses ” Blame: Smith’s Pacific—Berger cut amphibs ’19—FD2030’s fault-narrow dodges truth!

Narrow Cost

Smith’s FD2030—five loose fingers—MLR’s short—Taiwan’s one fight—China’s global—nation’s blind—“narrow kills don't reach!”Title 10—standalone—FD2030 fails “narrow’s treason!” bring back the MAGTF

MAGTF: 25,000 active—12 tank companies, 3,700 crew, M1E3s—12 infantry companies, 1,800 Marines—8 arty companies, M198s (16 batteries), HIMARS (8 batteries), 1,200 gunners—4 support companies, 800 Marines—3 MAW squadrons per MEF, F-35Bs, MV-22s, 2,000 aviators—40 amphibs—covers all!”—OOOOH-RAHH!

Bring back the MAGTF NOW

Semper Fi,

Task Force Ripper

Expand full comment
Thomas M. Huber's avatar

There is a great article in today's Guardian by Helen Davidson about China's new Shuqiao landing barges. Make amphibious landing possible at huge scale anywhere without beaches! A breakthrough. We should have thought of this. China's vast shipbuilding industry can build these fast, and they are building them.

Expand full comment
11 more comments...

No posts