Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jerry McAbee's avatar

I have always thought one of the better quotes for Operation Overload was Eisenhower's directive from the Combined Chiefs of Staff. It read, "You will enter the continent of Europe and, in conjunction with the other United Nations, undertake operations aimed at the heart of Germany and the destruction of her armed forces." Talk about a clear, concrete, and concise mission order. Compare that with the gobbledygook we see today trying to explain the virtues of EABO, FD, and SIF.

Expand full comment
Charles Wemyss, Jr.'s avatar

Further to General McAbee’s comments, it strikes this writer, that as amazing an effort as Operation Overlord was and remains today, the Marines in the Pacific had been conducting amphibious assaults against entrenched static defensive positions of the Japanese Imperial Navy and Army, prior to the landings in North Africa, Sicily and Italy and to include the first upon Guadalcanal, which very quickly in a sense turned on its ear, as the US Navy, was forced to vacate the battle space, leaving the Marines exposed to the Japanese’s Navy and Air Force as well as conducting offensive missions to take the island. The Marines prevailed, but lack of logistics could have become a factor if they had not overwhelmed and defeated the opponent. Thus we are supposed to believe the hokum (Gobbledygook was used already!) that the FD2030 proponents use to define a murky “first island chain” defensive posture, (EABO) with limited assets, (MLR/SIF) because the PLA/PLAN will ever know, see or grapple with forward “sensing” units and will not defend themselves against the firecrackers we intend to fire at their warships. Does FD2030 even contemplate one of the Principals of War? The Normandy Invasion included them all and it was still a dicey affair. Why use proven capabilities when you can invent new ones without merit? The roll up of the Japanese’s Imperial forces was a long slow defeat in detail. Why would anyone expect less of the FD2030 concept? Oh we know! Because it’s us!

This all said, Semper Fidelis to the fighting forces of 6 June 1944, that starting with the airborne pathfinders jumping in behind the Normandy beaches, took “light the way” took the fight further into Europe and sallied forward to defeat the combined force of the Nazi regime.

Expand full comment
18 more comments...

No posts