Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Charles Krulak's avatar

This Compass Points should give pause to all Marines...both Active Duty and Reserve. As noted, Balikatan was initially a formal exercise designed to enhance the interoperability of Marine Forces and those of the Philippines. It has obviously grown much larger in participation which is, for the Region, a good thing. What is concerning is the fact that the Army's 25th ID appears to have taken over the central role...with a focus on defeating an Amphibious Operation conducted by the PLA/PLAN. 7 years ago, the concept behind Force Design was essentially what the 25th ID demonstrated during Balikatan. To achieve this capability, the Army did not "Divest to Invest"...they did not emasculate existing capability to create what was seen at Balikatan 2026. Instead, they apparently resorted to the Marine Corps tried and true concept of task organizing! Here we are, 7 years + into Force Design and much of what we determined to be the requirements to exercise our EABO effort remain either still on the drawing board or in our hands but not in the quantity or quality needed for the fight we see ahead. Of particular concern is the Stand-in Force and the ability to resupply those Forces and, if necessary, evacuate dead and wounded. Again, 7 years into the Force Design and the long pole in the tent remains Logistics. The failure to initially utilize the MCCDC Combat Development Process to determine requirements prior to divestment has been noted multiple times. At the end of the day, "The Campaign of Learning" has proven to be a poor substitute for the proper use of the Combat Development Process.

Douglas C Rapé's avatar

No need to comment any further on ship sinking impotence. The Army, Navy and USAF are all much better positioned to sink enemy ships. Just out fitting USMC aviation assets to sink ships would yield benefits by July 4th. Why continue to expend resources to finish a distant fourth place in a four way race in a mission the USMC self selected.

As to the General’s tenure. Human performance center…yawn. 3D parts production. OK, an emergency measure when a flawed system cannot deliver the parts. Yup, no mention of EABO. Logistics is critical. Not in taking care of themselves but getting the right stuff, to the right places, on time.

10 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?