Discussion about this post

User's avatar
cfrog's avatar

Note #1: Ben Connable is a champ. His writing is methodical, thoughtful, and thought provoking. (referencing the War on the Rocks article posted by Grable. Excellent summary of how we got here and the issue of relevance to the Joint Force for the USMC today. Connable is not a fan of the implementation of FD, but takes the standpoint of 'here we are' let's move forward)

Note #2: I suspect the shipping container concept will turn out to be one of those ideas that briefs well on first pass, but falls apart the deeper one goes into serious implementation (especially, but not only for conventional ops).

Expand full comment
Raymond Lee Maloy's avatar

A sensible solution and analysis. Just like everything else in the inventory, we’ll require operators, maintenance, resupply, etc. In the final analysis, however, it will come down to a knock down, drag out fight with Infantry, Armor and Artillery to occupy the enemy territory.

I’m reminded of a quote in William Corson’s outstanding book “The Betrayal”. “Presidents pay your money and make a choice of Generals. If the choice is correct you get a victory; if not, you get promises from of things to come and alibis for past failures.”

He could have been writing about the present crops explanations about Force Design and for not meeting today’s commitments. Semper Fi

Expand full comment
17 more comments...

No posts